A new study in The Lancet warns that hip “resurfacing,” an alternative hip replacement procedure, results in earlier failure rates among women and smaller men.
Hip resurfacing operations are supposedly recommended for younger, more active patients who want a greater range of motion than afforded from a traditional replacement. Resurfacing is done for patients with the understanding that more surgery will be required as the joint continues to wear. However, researchers from the University of Bristol analyzed data from the National Joint Registry of England and Wales and found that the failure rate of resurfacing implants (5%) was much higher than that of traditional hip replacements (2%) after 5 years.
In addition to finding a higher overall failure rate, the researchers found that the early failure rate was “unacceptably high” for women, and significantly higher than average for men with smaller femoral heads. Only about 23% of men have large enough hip bones to fare well with this operation, the study found.
If you’re considering a hip surgery or joint replacement, it’s recommended that you speak candidly with your orthopaedic surgeon or sports medicine specialist about the best procedure for your lifestyle and expectations.
The Experts at the Bon Secours Orthopaedic Institute
At the Bon Secours Orthopaedic Institute, our orthopaedic team offers a comprehensive, compassionate approach to the prevention, assessment, treatment and rehabilitation of orthopaedic injuries and diseases. You will find, nationally respected orthopaedic surgeons who use leading edge technology that lessens pain and shortens recovery time, three joint and spine centers staffed by experts specializing in orthopaedic surgery and designed to optimize patient recovery and comfort, access to the largest comprehensive pain management center in Hampton Roads, and a team of clinical coordinators who help you navigate your pre- and post-op care. The experts at our Bon Secours Orthopaedic Institute are among the best in the region. Our team treats thousands of people every year, allowing them to regain pain-free stability and mobility. While we see many patients, we tailor our treatment plan to the unique needs of each individual who comes to us for help.
Source: The Advisory Board Company